TABLE 1. Quality Assessment for Case-Control Studies Using Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (n=17)

            Exposed and nonexposed individuals Exposure ascertained by    
Reference Independent validation of cases Appropriately selected cases must meet all 4 criteriaa Controls from same population as cases Explicit statement controls have no history of outcome Matched Matched by second factor Adjusted by 1 factor when no matching Adjusted by >1 factor when no matching Secure record (chart/file) Structured interviewb Same method of ascertaining cases and controls Response rates same for cases and controls
Brown et al,321997   Yes                 Yes  
Cachelin et al,34 2005   Yes Yes             Yes Yes  
Cheasty et al,7 1998   Yes Yes               Yes  
De Bellis et al,371994         Yes Yes     Yes      
Deep et al,381999     Yes Yes Yes Yes       Yes    
Figueroa et all,44 1997                   Yes Yes  
Garnefski et al,471992   Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes         Yes  
Pettigrew & Burcham,51 1997     Yes Yes         Yes      
Price et al,53 2002   Yes Yes   Yes       Yes Yes    
Roelofs et al,55 2002   Yes     Yes Yes       Yes Yes Yes
Spitzer et al,57 2008   Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes         Yes  
Steiger et al,58 2000       Yes             Yes  
Striegel-Moore et al,59 2002   Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes         Yes  
Stuart et al,601990       Yes Yes Yes         Yes  
Tanskanen et al,61 2004   Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes         Yes  
Welch & Fairburn,62 1996   Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes         Yes  
Wise et al,642001 Yes Yes Yes               Yes  

a. Criteria: (1) during defined period; (2) during defined area; (3) all cases in a defined group; (4) appropriate sample (random or consecutive). 
b. With blinding to measured outcome