Nature
of paedophile relationships
Answers
to the question concerning the kinds of relationships with children that are
engaged in are summarised in Table 13, with some of the more typical and
interesting responses given verbatim in Table 14. The most common descriptions
were in non-sexual terms such as affectionate, caring, loving, gentle, intimate,
platonic and fatherly. Only 18 subjects explicitly Four
subjects claimed they indulged in actual sexual relationships with children only
when overseas in countries where legal restrictions were absent or less strictly
enforced, e.g. Morocco, Sri Lanka, the Philippines. Three subjects made
reference to paying children for sexual services and two said that they liked
their sex play to include some mild spanking. Fleeting, casual encounters with
children were mentioned about as often as long-term relationships. It
should be noted that these various types of relationship are by no means
mutually exclusive; most of the subjects reported having several different kinds
of relationship with different children, either simultaneously or serially. It
was particularly The
impression gained from both the questionnaire answers and the more detailed
‘depth’ interviews was that subjects were reporting fairly honestly and
accurately on their behaviour. However, there is a possibility that the sexual
motive was being played down by some subjects either out of personal discretion
or for the cause of P1 E as a political organisation seeking public approval of
paedophilia. This consideration also applies to answers to some of the other
questions. |
TABLE
13
Ways
in which 77 paedophiles characterise their relationships with
Affectionate, loving, gentle, etc.
22
Deep, intimate, close
3
Non-sexual, platonic friendship
19
Fatherly
3
Genital sexuality involved (whether manua 18
oral or anal)
Sexual relationships overseas only
4
Fleeting, casual, playful
5
Long-term
7
Professional (payment made to child)
3
Spanking involved
2
None
5
|
TABLE
14 Nature
of relationships with children
|
TABLE
15
Main
types of fantasies concerning children (Numbers out of 77
Sexual activity
39
Romantic or caring
22
None
18
No answer
7
|
TABLE
16 Fantasies
of paedophiles
|
TABLE
17
Desired
behaviour if legal sanctions removed (main categories of
Give love, affection, protection, etc.
14
Engage in sexual activity, provided child agreeable
13
Same as now, but more openly
8
Cohabit or form lasting relationship
6
|
TABLE
18 Desired
behaviour if legal sanctions removed
|
TABLE
19
Happy, proud, positive feelings
27
Disturbed
21
Frustrated
13
Puzzled
11
Sad, hopeless, depressed
5
Accepting, reconciled
5
Guilty, ashamed
4
Bitter, angry (with society)
3
|
TABLE
20 Feelings
about the paedophile preference S7
‘I’m certainly puzzled but I’ve given up being disturbed. Many
people have secret areas of their lives, and this happens to be mine. S9
‘Happy. Contemptuous of hysteria currently coming from self-appointed
moral guardians who seem to know little of what children think and feel.’ S10
‘Associations with boys, even if limited to a purely platonic friendly
basis, are of paramount importance to me. My only problems are the restraints
imposed by society and my own diffidence even among children.’ S11
‘Although I like and enjoy my relationship with children, I am both
puzzled and disturbed by my sexual liking for them. Those I love, I also fear as
they have complete control over me and yet it is this that I long for.’ S13
‘Extremely disturbed. My depressive and antisocial nature I attribute
solely to this cause. I consider that it cripples my social life, my
relationship with family and friends, my career prospects, and my general peace
of mind. I am ashamed of it and frequently find it degrading and base.’ S14
‘Extremely happy and fulfilled in following any natural inclinations.
Only disturbed when confronted by the more “bull-necked” of my fellow men,
who wish to confine the infinite variety of sexual (and other) experience within
socially pre-scribed limits.’ S16
‘I wish very much that I were “normal” enough to have a loving
relationship with a woman and to marry and have a family of my own. S17
‘It’s a bloody nuisance really, in today’s world, but I believe
I’ve learned to live with it. I have many friends and a busy job and outside
interests which prevent me brooding (subconsciously?). These days I believe I
try to avoid contacts with children, much as I love them, to avoid
temptations.’ S18
‘I wonder why I have been afflicted with this torment which has no
outlet and for which people are punished. Often wish to end it all, seeing that
I will never get a relationship with any boy I like —even to have experienced
it would have been something.’ S20
‘I often wonder why, but have become resigned to the fact that it’s
part of me, so I don’t let it worry me too much. I sometimes wonder what
it’s like to be “normal”.’ S21
‘I believe it’s the work of Nature (not God, incidentally) so it must
be accepted by people. Obviously children need to be protected from people they
do not wish to have contact with. Repression leads to guilt - to inner conflicts
and mental disorders.’ S24
‘Was slightly worried and guilty until meeting and correspond-ing with
similar people. I still realise it’s a perversion in the basic meaning of the
word, but now feel I can live with it. I am also strongly attracted to mature
women (i.e. to age of 38 say) and enjoy several relationships.’ S32
‘Happy morally, distressed socially. I am unashamed in that I am
convinced it is harmless to them, beneficial to both parties and utterly
innocent. But so long as society says it is harmful, corrupting, wicked and
punishable I remain frustrated and very, very sad.’ S33
‘Consider society in general evil in its treatment of children under
the guise of “protection”, “what’s best for them”, etc. In reality the
child is never consulted or considered. Absolute bigotry and hypocrisy.’ S35
‘Very happy about it, except for the fact that it is illegal, and in
our culture it is hard to find kids that are “into” it. Would in addition
like to be able to respond to women, if only so I could marry and raise a family
of my own beautiful children.’ S46
‘I no longer feel guilt about my preference and to that extent am happy
about it. It feels absolutely right and natural to me. The worst part of it is
the continual sense of frustration and the infrequent opportunity of talking
openly about boys without evoking shock or disapproval.’ S45
‘I think I have come to terms with it now, though it took a long time.
So I’m reasonably happy about it, but unhappy about the need for secrecy and
deception and angry about the possible consequences of its revelation.’ S54
‘I feel that this is something that separates me from other people and
this is basically the cause of my other problems - e.g. lack of success in the
working environment.’ S55
‘Very bitter to think that there are so many people like myself who
give so much love and happiness to children, but are ruthlessly hunted down by
members of a heartless society.’ S62
‘Probably the same as Black or Jewish people feel about themselves. My
paedophilia is an integral and good part of my total personality. The stresses
it imposes are entirely the product of society’s hostility.’ S68
‘I am the man God made me. As such I am testimony to his infinite
variety. My personality is a talent to be used in his honour. It is the driving
force of my work for young people and the inspiration of my poems and writing. I
am a happy man.’ S71
‘Sad that at present it is socially unacceptable and can provoke
unwelcome consequences. But otherwise no problems. I’d spend no more time
pondering my “preference” than the average worker wonders why he likes page
3 of the Sun.’
Treatment
experiences
Question
13 asked whether subjects had ever sought professional advice or treatment, and
if so, from what kind of person or institution. Table 21 summarises the types of
treatment that were attempted and the outcome. The majority had not sought any
treatment, either because they did not acknowledge that there was anything wrong
with them (‘it’s society that’s sick’) or because they felt their
preference was so deep-rooted as to be irremediable. Of those who did find their
way to treatment most reported having seen a psychiatrist. (Of course, they may
not all have been able to distinguish this description from others, such as
psychoanalyst and psychologist, that were less frequently cited.) Three had seen
counsellors from the Albany Trust, which is a charity sympathetic to
homosexuals. One subject said he was ‘forced by the courts’ to take
treatment, another was given treatment in prison, and a third was advised before
his trial that the court might treat him more leniently if he was known to be
having treatment for his problem. Not all subjects who had seen medical
authorities presented paedophilia as their prime complaint. Three sought their
treatment for depression, one for migraine and another for fear of dentistry. Group
therapy and drugs were mentioned as the approach to treatment by three subjects
each. The others did not specify the nature of their therapy, but it is probable
that insight-oriented ‘talk’ therapy was a major component in most cases. A
few patients mentioned that aversion therapy had been offered to them, usually
half-heartedly, and all had declined. Of
those who made some comment relating to the outcome of therapy thirteen said
that it was of no help to them at all, while none reported any beneficial
effects. One subject said that his psychiatrist treated his anxiety over his
predilection for boys so effectively that he became careless over his contacts
and got himself arrested. Other comments of some interest are shown in Table 23. |
TABLE
21
TYPES
Psychiatrist
17
Psychoanalyst
2
Psychologist
2
GP
3
Counsellor from Albany Tru
3
Student Counsellor
1
Group Therapy
3
Drugs
3
Forced by courts, pre-trial or in prison 3
None sought
46
OUTCOME
Beneficial
0
Unsuccessful
13
|
TABLE
22 Experience
of professional advice and treatment S10
‘Yes, some years ago when I attempted also to fit myself into the gay
scene. Through my G P I was first offered aversion therapy which I rejected.
Tried group therapy - no go; tried psycho-analysis (analyst finally sent me
away). Felt non-authentic in homosexual relationships, so settled down to being
myself.’ S19
‘Yes, a psychiatrist. A pleasant young man, but we never really made
contact. To him, I was a “case”, to me, he was a man I was advised to
contact, prior to my trial in the courts.’ S21
‘Yes, from psychiatrists and psychologists. Mental therapy which led to
depression, so treatment discontinued. Also drugs used to suppress to no avail.
I have come to the opinion after so much treatment that the only person who can
help a paedophile is himself. All treatment I thought was useless. There should
be more research into what makes a person paedophile, which I think is the
environment the child is brought up in. From my own personal experience once a
person becomes a paedophile he is like it for the rest of his life, to some
degree or other.’ S30
‘From a doctor who said the only thing she knew was aversion therapy,
which she did not recommend. Have talked to priests who are very helpful.’ S38
‘Twice in prison, but found no help under their care. I felt it was all
a ritual which they had to enact so that forms could be filled in. They showed
no interest, spent most of time yawning, their attitudes being, “we have heard
it all”.’ S40
‘No, the only advice I would ever seek professionally would be legal
advice, or else NCCL, if I were ever charged with an offence relating to my
sexuality by the police. Treatment is a complete misnomer. Do heterosexuals need
treatment to prevent them giving love?’ S45
‘Several years ago, I went (voluntarily) into a mental hospital for a
few days’ observation for depression and eventually discussed it with the
registrar, but declined aversion therapy, which was all that was offered.’ S48
‘Under parental pressure, I consulted a specialist (a psychiatrist
attached to the local hospital). He simply said that if I was committed in this
particular direction he could do nothing about it. He counselled me not to break
the law.’ S57
‘No, why should I, with all the broken homes, etc. there would seem to
be a need for us.’ S77
‘I have always felt that if I could not change myself into a
heterosexual nobody else would change me. I have found this theory to be right
in later years. TABLE
23 Other
Comments
S11
‘I cannot understand why I like being hurt in my private parts, by
kneeing and kicking. Also suffocating by having the soft stomach lying on my
face. My supreme obedience and sub-mission as soon as his body touches mine.’ S12
‘I am a loving person. I need to love and be loved not by one person
but many. Once I had 23 boys on the go, in different relationships, some as long
as 3 years. If my kid is happy so am I, that is my motto (Freedom for Boys).’ S14
‘Presumably like any other sexual experience this seems to me to vary
greatly from individual to individual (both on the adult and the child’s side
of any relationship) and is basically the loving response of someone to the
needs of another human being - a
state of affairs which may or may not last, just as needs vary on either side. I
do not consider myself a threat to the institution of marriage or to any other
institution, and I would say the same of the few other paedophiles I have
known.’ S15
‘I would simply like to see a greater recognition of the civil law and
less insistence on increasing the number of criminal laws and their punitive
aspects. If children are attracted to adults it’s natural that some
reciprocation occurs. At present child batterers are more respected than
molesters.’ S16
‘I know that my close relationships with boys have usually been of
benefit to them. I know of no case where it has been otherwise. Some are now
married with families, and still visit me. In one case I certainly saved an
11-year-old from a nervous breakdown by giving him all I had in the way of
affection and support.’ S18
‘My only outlets are my imagination and memory of people seen. Odd
trips to Denmark where I found no physical contact; photos. I have been trying
my own auto-suggestion methods based on books. Sometimes I get through whole
days without being bothered. Holidays are the worst times. I even try to avoid
places where children go as I know I can never be successful with any,
especially here. My hand is my only sexual outlet. I reckon I will die
unfulfilled sexually. How I wish I did not have this affliction. If I have to
destroy my pictures I will have nothing.’ S19
‘There is a mountain of evidence that paedophilia is a fact of life and
is only remotely connected with child molestation. The latter I am entirely
incapable of doing, though I am condemned for it. There is an urgent need for
education on the subject in society.’ S23
‘Obviously my sexual interests are an extension of childish fancies,
but this satisfies me. With females of any age I have a spanking addiction.
Playing with young girl’s bottoms, and handling their knickers is great.’ S24
‘The only time I hate myself is when I am very frustrated I go out
“hunting” hoping to seek an opportunity for some quick illicit sex. This
happens maybe once a month at most. In six years it has only once been
successful. Less frequent since starting a relationship with a beautiful boy of
9.’ S25
‘I cannot understand people’s hostility and suspicion towards adults
who live alone. When they go in supermarkets they are always watched with
suspicion. When they are arrested they are robbed of all they possess with the
help of probation officers, etc’ S27
‘As a child I viewed all this sex in a healthy and a happy way till I found
out it was unlawful. I am depressed ever since.’ S30
‘I take Christianity seriously and like to think that my attitude to the
children I fancy is as Christ-like as I can make it.’ S31
‘There should be no punishment for loving or touching children or
seeing them unclothed. But definitely punishment for un-wanted sex or assault
and neglect. Violence is condoned - love punished.’ S34
‘I like to think of myself as a helper and mentor to my young friends.
With some I am a lover as well, but to all I am a friend.’ S35
‘I feel paedophilia is at the core of my identity; I couldn’t change
my orientation without becoming a totally different person, with different
aesthetic perceptions, affectual responses and even political sympathies. I am
happy with myself as I am because I feel (a) morally sound (b) I am able to live
a reasonably balanced life despite the obvious difficulties (c) I feel we
paedophiles are privileged to have a view of the world that is denied to
most.’ S39
‘I am really only interested in a mutual loving relationship with a
boy. I do not force my attentions on children and feel annoy & that most
people do not (or will not) see the difference between my behaviour and that of
those people who need to use violence for their ephemeral pleasures.’ S46
‘The visual component of sex is important to me - seeing adolescent
boys naked, singly or in groups, is a physical and aesthetic delight of great
intensity. Obviously I would like the age of consent lowered to say 14 - but I
think it important to safeguard boys from having unwelcome sexual attentions
forced on them.’ S51
‘I do not regard myself as a pervert. Those who cannot be deeply moved
by the wonder of a beautiful child, those who are indifferent, those are the
true perverts.’ S59
‘If children had not been intended to enjoy sexual acts before they
were able to reproduce, they would not have been given the capability of orgasm.
Puritanical bigotry is denying them their God-given right. It is hoped that this
survey, in which I have been pleased to participate, will help to bring about a
more enlightened, tolerant and less bigoted view of paedophilia, and its
acceptance as a recognised manifestation of human sexuality and not a freak
sexual deviation.’ S77
‘Unlike some others like myself I have always looked for a one-to-one
relationship, and with the right partner, take no interest in looking for other
boys.’ |